Remember, months and months ago, when I wrote a few posts about Diaper Free Babies? Well, I thought I’d check back in and let you know how things are going.
If you need a moment to reacquaint yourself with the previous posts, here they are: An Introduction, Adventures with Lydia, and Lastly, Sarah.
So, Mitch and I assumed that EC with a second child would be harder, take longer and would probably be a sporadic affair, but we hadn’t counted on one huge advantage: we’ve done this before. With Lydia fully out of diapers, our day naturally includes trips to the bathroom, and the habit of leaving a child in a diaper for hours is not one we had to unlearn. When changing diapers, it’s second nature to sit Sarah on the potty for a minute (just in case) or to cue her if we know she’s going potty in her diaper.
Even then, though, we weren’t nearly as deliberate about EC with Sarah: we took her to the potty when we could, not every time we thought she needed to go, and she still wore diapers most of the time.
However – and this is an important “however” – somehow, EC took. I hadn’t thought much about it in a while, between moving and getting used to our new routine, but one day, Sarah just wouldn’t stay out of the bathroom. Sheesh, I thought, hauling her out each time, only to find her in the bathroom again a few minutes later.
Apparently, I just wasn’t getting the message, so the next time I went into the bathroom after her, I found her trying to climb onto the (closed!) toilet.
And the light bulb went on.
“Do you need to go potty?” I asked. Sarah nodded vigorously and said, “Yep!”
Just like that. Now, I don’t want to count my chickens before they hatch, of course, but she seems so close to graduation we can almost smell the absence of diapers in our house. I’ve even taken her out shopping without a diaper (but with a spare change of clothes), and she’s often in training pants for hours while we’re at home.
It’s that last part that I really want to share with you, since I’ve had a few potty-training moms ask me about cloth training pants recently. What we do is very simple, and results in few puddles: we use these simple, cheap trainers, and put them under fleece or wool pants. The pants absorb the extra, but if she does miss, she feels wet enough to come tell us that something’s up.
To be fair, Sarah still tells us after the fact when she does some bigger business in her britches, but the trainers keep everything contained, if you will, so I don’t think that’s any worse to clean up than if she was in a cloth diaper (especially if you have a diaper sprayer – spendy, but worth it). All in good time, though. We’ll get there.
So, with Lydia, we relied on timing – taking her to the potty when we thought she needed to go – while Sarah, who knows how to get what she wants, tells us, in one way or another, that it’s time. Sometimes she climbs on the toilet, sometimes she looks me in the eye, babbling earnestly away, and pats her pants. Sometimes, I ask if she needs to go and she yells, “NO!” and runs the other way. So one assumes that she isn’t interested.
Before I finish, I do want to mention one thing: I’m under the impression that people see this, some times, as a lot of work, more work than conventional potty-training, and I cannot stress enough that it just isn’t. EC is just a different routine: say, the process of potty-training begun earlier and diluted over a longer period of time. I didn’t do any more laundry than I would have if I’d been cloth-diapering full time. I’ve really enjoyed introducing the girls to the potty as babies, rather than toddlers, because they take it as par for the course (and there are no power struggles). Using the potty isn’t a new concept: it’s what they’ve always done.
That said, I cannot emphasize enough that every family is different, and it is always my goal to respect that. This is not a one-size-fits-all solution, and I know that there are a thousand decisions that we must make as parents: to do EC with Sarah, I elected to buy her baby food, rather than make it, because I just couldn’t do both with two kids. I’m just happy to share what’s worked for us because it’s worked so well, and because it seems a bit misunderstood.
I suppose the moral of our story is: EC is worth trying. Especially, when faced with the prospect of a diaper free 18-month-old who doesn’t realize that she’s doing something awesome, I would say that it’s very worth trying.